Nabooru, the Gerudo, and the Orientalism criticism
The Gerudo have been criticized for drawing on Orientalist imagery. This page summarizes what critics argue, what the games show, and where the debate is still open. It does not hand down a verdict.
What Orientalism means on this page
Edward Said’s term, as Wikipedia’s Gerudo article uses it, is not “any desert detail is bad.” It names a habit of painting a huge region as exotic, backward, sensual, and dangerous so that another culture can look orderly by comparison. I use the word that way, and only when a cited writer uses it.
What the 1998 design shows
Wikipedia’s Gerudo article, drawing on the game, describes an all-female desert people introduced in Ocarina of Time: dark skin, red hair, often taller than Hylians, scimitars, a foreign-sounding language, and clothing read as belly-dance costume. A star-and-crescent mark was removed from later material. Nabooru’s own line, on Zelda Wiki, says the Gerudo have a male child once a century. Those are design facts from two pages. They are not yet an argument.
What critics argue
Most of the following reaches me through Wikipedia’s summary of each writer. I did not re-copy sentences from Mic, Waypoint, or the essays themselves, so I attribute the points as “as summarized there,” except for Byron J. Kimball, whose paper abstract is also on Western Oregon University’s site.
- Ryan Khosravi (Mic, 2017), via Wikipedia: Breath of the Wild continues a questionable portrayal, mixing Southwest Asian and South Asian cues — language, scimitars, a desert town — and the Ocarina of Time “thieves” lean on a cunning-stranger stereotype.
- Hussain Almahr (Waypoint, 2017), via Wikipedia: Gerudo gender rules echo some Muslim-majority settings with the roles flipped. He found pieces of the town visually familiar and the whole thing closer to decoration. Link’s visit could have been a real culture shock; the game mostly lets him watch.
- Byron J. Kimball (2018): the game “others” the Gerudo so Western colonialism can look benign, with Link as a white savior. Three Gerudo models against many Hylian ones make the group feel less individual. Clothes, images, and chanted language mark them as danger.
- Laurence Herfs, via Wikipedia: an “oriental other,” called savage in Ocarina of Time, still framed by carpet, small windows, and dance costume later. Token vocabulary, hooked-nose caricature, and sexualization, including of younger characters, stack a Western gaze on a Japanese one.
- Johnathan Sanders (2021), via Wikipedia: bandits, the only humanoid enemies you may attack freely, ruled by the villain, plus the deleted crescent, read to him as Islamophobic.
Counterpoints, including inside the same article
Jessica Ramos (Yahoo, 2021), again via Wikipedia’s summary, argues there is room to celebrate: Gerudo introduce players to another culture, and the clothes evoke Middle Eastern ideas without only being villains. Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom give the people a town, a chief, and heroes such as Urbosa and Riju. That later writing does not erase the 1998 enemy role. It does stop me from calling the whole series one stereotype.
Nintendo has not published a reply to this criticism. I will not invent one. The 2026 remake’s ESRB card dropping “Suggestive Themes” is a CBR inference, not a studio statement about Orientalism, so I leave it off this page’s conclusion. The outfit comparison itself is on the cosplay page and the remake page.
Questions people ask
Did Nintendo respond?
I have not found a public response.
Is this page a ruling?
No. It lines up the design, the critics, and the replies, and it names which points I only have second-hand.